Montreal new park benches under fire – unfriendly to homeless


When a few years ago, under then – Mayor Denis Coderre, Cabot Square underwent a renovation, those who designed its new look had to reconcile different views on its character. While Cabot Sq. is partly located in a residential area, it is also a transit hub serving a shopping centre, a cinema complex, various stores, a big college, and office buildings.

The new Cabot Sq. was to accommodate the interests of a variety of people: residents who want to take a walk in the park, commuters waiting for buses, and during the summer, the staging of artistic activities.  However, Cabot Sq. had also become a meeting place for a group that would soon be recognized as an important presence in the area.  Those people were mostly Inuit who stay at a Y facility at the old Reddy Memorial.  They also received some services at a now-closed church nearby, and who during the day tend to hang out in the square. In the winter those people gather at the entrance of the Atwater station, in the summer they use the park as a place to stay, to relax, or even sleep.

It is at this point where the square becomes a temporary residence for homeless people when the benches, installed after the renovation of the square, became an issue. The benches are made of wood, with metallic partitions which would make it hard for anyone wanting to lay down on them. In other words, these pieces of urban furniture are designed as seats, and to use them to lay down or sleep is certainly discouraged.

This situation doesn’t go well with some, and indeed it has created heated debates in the social networks.  For some, these benches are indications of discriminatory and even racist practices in our city. “The only place they can go, they have benches that clearly state this is not for you,” Nakuset, executive director of Native Women’s Shelter and Resilience Montreal said in an interview with City News. She also pointed out that the “controversial benches in Cabot Square are part of a wider problem.”

Certainly, the point she made is an interesting one, but not as much as to the benches themselves, but in suggesting that there is a “wider problem” on which she doesn’t elaborate, but it is obviously a reference to the various forms of systemic racism in our society. In this particular case, aiming at indigenous people.

However, in focusing on the design of the benches, the critical questions of racism and discrimination may go missing. The benches are designed to prevent people from laying down on them. All right. In principle that’s what park benches are for: they are not for sleeping. The real racist story here is that some people for the sad reason that they are homeless, and in this case, indigenous, are forced to spend their nights sleeping on a park bench. Recent attempts, sometimes with the best of intentions, to generate sympathy and acceptance of homeless people in parks, streets, metro stations, are resulting in what could indeed be described as a perverse effect: the normalization of homelessness. The question then is not park benches being “unfriendly” to homeless people, but the fact that this society is becoming used to people having no place to sleep. By accepting homelessness as a “normal” feature of urban life, people become desensitized to the drama behind this phenomenon. Even worse, if park benches become suitable for laying down, that would be a band-aid solution. What is needed instead are, in the short term, more shelters for the homeless complemented by community spaces where they can socialize, learn some skills, and get counselling and treatment for addiction when needed. In the long term, social housing. The option of sleeping in a park is itself a discriminatory practice that should not be accepted as “normal.” Let’s then separate, the essential finding real solutions for homelessness, from the contingent, those urban artefacts that in the grand scheme of things are irrelevant.

Other top articles from and

Crescent Street now pedestrian only

Montreal’s Crescent Street now pedestrian only for the summer

Hyperloop high speed train Montreal to Toronto under 40 minutes (video) – Montreal would become a suburb of Toronto

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Coronavirus vaccine approved in U.K.

The light at the end of the tunnel seems to be here. British government officials have authorized a COVID-19 vaccine for use to treat emergency cases. This is the world’s first Coronavirus vaccine approved by any country. The vaccine has been produced by the American drugmaker Pfizer and Germany’s BioNTech. “It’s fantastic said British Prime

Promenade Wellington Christmas

Promenade Wellington Christmas ‘Le Coeur sur la Well’

Promenade Wellington launched its ‘’Le Coeur sur la Well’’ Christmas campaign on November 20 to support its local merchants and bring a little warmth and enchantment to the community.  To get into the holiday mood There’s nothing better than Christmas music and decorations to set the mood for the holidays! Come experience the magic of


18 TO PARTY: Teenage anxieties, dreams, and UFOs

A little bit of nostalgia for those growing up in the 1980s is what this movie brings: Reagan is in the White House, critical times in the economy, and yes, the recurrent topic of UFOs is not far from the thoughts of this group of teenagers. The boys and girls who make up the group

amazing cheese recipes

Three amazing cheese recipes you have to try

As the temperature drops and the days get darker, who doesn’t want warm and comforting plates of goodness?  Cheese lovers, get ready for a cozy night at home with these three recipes with Montasio, Asiago Stagionato, and Grana Padano European PDO cheeses. Mac and cheese, an all-time favourite When sweater weather comes around, there is

COVID-19 cases rising across Quebec schools

COVID-19 cases rising across Quebec schools

Although Quebec’s CAQ government continues to maintain that Covid-19 cases in schools across the province remain stable – the numbers published by their own Ministry of Education do not appear to uphold those conclusions. Their data includes pre-school, elementary and high schools in both the public and private sectors (as well as vocational and adult

electric scooters

Are you supposed to allow your children to ride electric scooters?

Like almost anything, electric scooters can be safe or dangerous depending on the operator. The technology powering Green electric scooters has advanced to the point where it is extremely safe in comparison to where they were in the past. Nowadays, you will find electric scooters with world-class braking technology, improved speed restriction, and even better

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox