Classic movies yesterday questionable today- Peter Pan, Dumbo, Gone with the wind and more.

Classic movies

In these times, streaming classic movies —which had already gained popularity before the pandemic—has become essential for movie fans. Providers of these services, for their part, also have the power to decide what to offer. This is not much in terms of new productions, since many have postponed their release dates. However, these companies also have vast collections of classic films, a potential treasure for older audiences willing to enjoy them again.  For younger audiences interested in cinema as an art form, those classic movies provide a valuable source about its evolution.

Frankly my dear, I don’t give a damn – Gone with the wind (1939)

However, watching classic movies from a bygone era presents sometimes a problem.  A kind of cultural disjointedness may occur, particularly while today’s audiences are confronted with movies containing views that may be at odds with contemporary values. One typical case was that of “Gone with the Wind” the classic 1939 film directed by Victor Fleming and set during the American Civil War. Clark Gable and Vivien Leigh were the main characters in that romantic story. However, later, Hattie McDaniel (Mammy) has caught much attention: she was the black servant and somehow confidant of the beautiful Scarlett O’Hara, the plantation owner’s daughter. The film has been categorized as racist for its portrayal of blacks and a veiled sympathetic depiction of slave-owners’ Southerners. Thus, HBO decided to remove the movie this past summer, in the middle of the protests for the killing of George Floyd and the Black Lives Matter movement’s rise. The streaming company announced then that the movie would eventually be reinstated with a “new introduction by Black scholar and television host Jacqueline Stewart.”

Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah song

The Walt Disney Studios, through its streaming service Disney+, acted more drastically completely excluding its “Song of the South” from its catalogue. In a statement issued last year, Disney executive chairman Bob Iger said that the movie was “not appropriate in today’s world.” The 1946 film, that combined live-action and animation, featured James Baskett as Uncle Remus, a black old man working in a plantation during the so-called reconstruction period in the American south. Uncle Remus enjoyed telling stories to Johnny, a white boy, while blacks were portrayed as having a happy life there. The movie, denounced as racist, can no longer be seen on Disney+ although at the time it was very successful. Its song “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah” composed by Allie Wrubel with lyrics by Ray Gilbert, won the Academy Award for Best Original Song.

Peter Pan – What Makes The Red Man Red

While an undeniable racist undertone can be detected in “Song of the South,” other decisions by Disney recently made public might be more controversial. The corporation decided to remove from its children section classic movies such as “Peter Pan”, “Dumbo”, and “The Aristocats.” The reason given was that they “promote damaging stereotypes.” The films will still be available in the general section.

I am puzzled by the case of “Peter Pan,” a beautiful 1953 animation film which strangely, will not be available for children, and is accused of stereotyping indigenous people.  I find that on the contrary, it presents a sympathetic view of them. In one part of the story, the tribe’s chief’s daughter was kidnapped by villain Captain Hook, and Peter rescued her.  The chief actually appreciated Peter and the film portrayed the indigenous man in a dignified way.

“Peter Pan” one of Disney’s classic and most beautiful animation films has been deemed not suitable for children

For their part, “Dumbo” (1941) and “The Aristocats” (1970) were removed due to scenes where, indirectly, Afro-Americans and Asians, respectively, were depicted stereotypically. Of course, cinema—and all its current video variants—with its combination of image, words, and music is a powerful medium. In that capacity, it might exert great influence on people, especially young children. However, freedom of expression too is a significant value to consider and to which children should also be introduced. While it seems evident that expressions aimed at belittling, humiliating, or promoting hate against a group in society should be banned, depictions of events as they were perceived at a particular time should be approached differently.  They may be accompanied by some explanatory introduction outlining the period’s cultural circumstances, as some streaming companies are already doing. Banning a film, however, should only happen after a thorough examination of the issues. After all, censorship—a threat that filmmakers have traditionally faced—should not be reinforced either. But certainly, these are complex times, and often it’s hard to balance respect for groups historically oppressed and the freedom necessary for artistic creation.

Feature image: Scarlett O’Hara (Vivien Leigh) and her servant Mammy (Hattie McDaniel) in “Gone with the Wind”: submissive blacks and a sympathetic look at slave-owner Southerners led HBO to remove the classic film 

By: Sergio Martinez – info@mtltimes.ca

Other articles from mtltimes.catotimes.caotttimes.ca

REM runs first train on tracks

First REM runs on tracks (video)

Airlines suspend flights

Airlines suspend flights to sun destinations immediately

La Poutine week starts next week – 120 participating Montreal Restaurants

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on email
Email
Is it possible to get an A for a 5-paragraph essay assignment in 1 hour? We can safely say yes, a student can get an A+ mark if he turns to EduJungles


Squid Games

The dawn of “Squid Games”: Best Korean dramas to watch In 2021-2022

Korean dramas have been sweeping the world and captivating audiences for decades. The genre has found success in both Korea and abroad, but now that is beginning to change. As global tastes are changing, Koreans realize that they need to produce content that will appeal to their international audiences like ‘Squid Games’. “Squid Games” is

Money transfer

How to transfer money from one bank to another

Advancements in technology have made it easier for people to move money from one payment platform to another. The increased penetration of the internet has made online money transfer a favourite option for those who don’t like handling cash. Many people have bank accounts in different financial and investment institutions. It could be a savings

Canada’s cannabis market

Ghost drops partners with Atlas Growers to go global

Ghost Drops has already conquered Canada’s cannabis market – twice. Once as an icon of underground cannabis culture, and again as a culture-jamming disruptor in the legal marijuana market. Now, one of the country’s most recognizable brands is making moves into the global market thanks to its new partnership with Atlas Growers. The move will

Saving Chinatown

Jimmy Chan delivers wake-up call with new documentary “Saving Chinatown”

Saving Chinatown – It’s difficult to see a city, suburb or neighbourhood become the victim of age, neglect, apathy and multi-million-dollar real estate development that can easily hinder or harm its heritage, or even worse, obliterate its existence that would render it just a slowly faded memory. That was the case of Montreal’s Chinatown district.

Online legal marketing

Online legal marketing: A trend all lawyers should follow

Online marketing has been seen to be a great boom for many companies – from small businesses to big corporations, all have been making the best use of the power of social media and online marketing to generate revenue. As businesses from all around the world are reaching customers in every part of the globe,

std testing

Where to get std testing in Montreal

General statistics estimate that nearly 40,000 people are reported as having sexually transmitted and blood-borne infections (STBBI carriers). This is in addition to the 75% of all adults with HPV infections throughout their lifetime. Studies have also shown that the number of gonorrhea infections has tripled in recent years. To protect yourself and others, receiving

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox