Sir John A. MacDonald Montreal statue not to be removed

Layout 1

Did you know that this past January 11 was Sir John A. MacDonald Day? Probably not, and even if you heard anything about our first prime minister lately, it might not have been something good: just weeks before, his statue, erected in Place du Canada, had been defaced by vandals. Regardless of the motives for the action, which came in a context of historical revisionism, the attack on the statue is regrettable: the monument to Sir John A. is one of the finest works of public art in the city. However, the question goes beyond this act: the historical role of this most famous Father of Confederation has been put into question in light of the terrible damage inflicted by the policy of putting young aboriginals in residential schools, apparently with the purpose of “civilizing them” and in the process, making them forget their culture and ancestry. Although MacDonald himself was not the proponent of this policy, it was under his tenure as Prime Minister that it was introduced.

Last August, the City of Victoria, B.C., announced the removal of a MacDonald’s statue from the front of city hall. In Montreal, Mayor Valerie Plante dismissed the suggestion to have the statue removed, but she announced last year and reiterated just a few days ago, her intention to work with the indigenous community to implement new policies of reconciliation. In particular by forming an ad-hoc committee which should look for a new name for Amherst Street, a far more prominent historical irritant. This committee will be composed entirely by indigenous people.

Although the involvement of Jeffrey Amherst with a kind of biological warfare against the indigenous people was well known, it has been only now that his genocidal role has been fully exposed and condemned. Historical records document that Amherst conspired with another officer –Colonel Henry Bouquet– to distribute blankets infected with smallpox among the indigenous tribes that were battling the British during the Pontiac’s War (1763-1764). Actually, this type of warfare was not invented by Amherst, two centuries earlier it had been used by Spanish conquistador Hernan Cortes in his war of conquest against the Aztecs in what is now Mexico. Cortes introduced an infected slave among the natives thus spreading the disease against which the Aztecs, and in general all aboriginals in the New World, had no defences. Millions of aboriginals died as a consequence of viruses introduced by the European colonizers, sometimes unwillingly, sometimes deliberately, as Cortes and then Amherst did.

Alexis Diomedi in his work “The biological warfare in the conquest of the new world” wrote: “Five centuries ago the European invaders arrived in the New World. They carried with them what turned out to be their main allies in the conquest of the continent: smallpox, measles and influenza viruses. In an attempt to recompose the process of dissemination of such diseases, a systematic review of the biomedical and historical literature was performed, to investigate how the Spaniards first, and the British later, used mainly smallpox to undertake a biological warfare against the American Indians, which eventually meant the biggest population catastrophe that America has never suffered in all its history.”

Not surprisingly, with this background, Amherst will soon be gone from Montreal’s street index. Instead, the downtown east-end street will carry an indigenous name. While demotion is the fate for Amherst, Sir John A.’s statue will likely stay. The Mayor is right in this case, after all, MacDonald was not the direct proponent of the notorious residential schools (in fact this was an imperial policy: aboriginals in Australia were subjected to similar treatment). On the other hand, it is a well-known fact that notable historical figures have committed some disgraceful acts: despite speaking against slavery, Thomas Jefferson owned about 600 slaves (he released six), Churchill was instrumental in the creation of concentration camps in South Africa, and so on with many others now honoured with streets named after them. Montreal must emphasize reconciliation with the first nations and demote those who committed crimes against them, but each case must be carefully examined. After all, two wrongs don’t make a right.

By: Sergio Martinez –

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

wild boar seen in Magog

Wild Boar seen in Magog area – residents on alert

We have seen an increase in wild animals in and around the Island of Montreal during the pandemic. There have been more and more sightings reported of coyotes, skunks and foxes. Just this past November a flock of wild turkeys took a romp through the Plateau-Mont-Royal area. Even raccoons and squirrels have become bolder in

history of counselling therapy

A brief history of counselling therapy

The history of counselling therapy can be traced back to Ancient Greece when the Greeks first identified mental illness as a medical condition and not spiritual. Human beings have always found comfort in sharing their troubles with others. Many people have differing theories for the origin of counselling therapy. Below is a brief history of

Control on Online Casinos

Legislation – The control on online casinos

Gambling laws and control on online casinos is a very complex subject that is different in every country. You may find some countries that embrace the gambling world, whereas others do anything to completely ban it. Moreover, you can come across different jurisdictions that take on different approaches to online casinos. The US is one

snow storm alert

UPDATE – Snow storm alert – up to 25 cm expected

Snow storm alert – The first significant snowfall in Montreal this season is expected tomorrow Saturday, January 16, 2021. Total snowfall amounts will reach 15 to 25 centimetres by Sunday morning January 17, 2021. Rapidly accumulating snow will make travel difficult. Visibility may be suddenly reduced at times in heavy snow. High concentrations of fine

La Poutine Week 2021

La Poutine Week 2021 delivery edition

La Poutine week 2021 is From February 1st until February 7th and delivered by SkiptheDishes to help empower the Canadian restaurant industry, restaurateurs, servers, and foodies – all in celebration of poutine. This year, La Poutine Week is serving YOU – allowing poutine lovers to discover new venues and savour unique poutines, while providing the

COVID-19 testing and screening

COVID-19 testing and screening in Canada

Since the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Government of Canada has used the latest science and evidence to inform our response. By collaborating with scientists and experts, we are ensuring the provinces and territories have the tools they need to make informed testing and screening decisions. As part of that effort, today, the COVID-19

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox