Zombie-Attack on Statue of Sir John A. Macdonald?

Zombie-Attack-on-Statue-of-Sir-John-A.-Macdonald-min

Zombie-Attack on Statue of Sir John A. Macdonald – I guess not many people today would have doubts about the shameful treatment given to the aboriginal peoples of Canada. Forcefully displaced from their traditional lands, settled in reservations that often couldn’t satisfy their basic needs, their children sent to residential schools where their culture was erased –these are some of the historical injustices to which they were subjected. 

Successive governments have apologized for those past actions –the current prime minister already did, and just a few weeks ago the Quebec premier also asked for forgiveness for the province’s treatment of the aboriginals in its territory. However, most people would agree that those words and intentions are not yet met with concrete action. 

Statue of Sir John A. Macdonald, an easy target

In response to official inaction, some people have taken the initiative to respond. Social mobilization and protest are usual ways by which citizens may respond. However, while meeting an unjust situation with an act of rebellion is justified, the question is what form this social reaction will take, and whether such form is the most adequate.

On October 31, a group that calls itself the “Anti-colonial zombies of the Old Saint-Antoine Cemetery, buried under Dorchester Square and Place du Canada” issued a statement in which it claimed responsibility for a new attack on the statue of Sir John A. Macdonald, located on the northern side of Place du Canada, facing Rene Levesque Boulevard. The monument was attacked with orange paint. 

Zombie-Attack on Statue of Sir John A. Macdonald?

In its press release, the Anti-colonial Zombies stated: “You have covered us in asphalt, concrete, and colonial-themed parks. You have desecrated our memories with monuments to the architects of genocide, like the racist John A. Macdonald, who attacked the culture and traditions of the Indigenous peoples of Turtle Island.” (According to the Canadian Encyclopedia, “Turtle Island is the name many Algonquian –and Iroquoian-speaking peoples mainly in the northeastern part of North America use to refer to the continent. In various Indigenous origin stories, the turtle is said to support the world, and is an icon of life itself.”)

Basically, Sir John A. Macdonald is accused of instituting the residential school system whose aim was to assimilate the indigenous people and destroy their cultures and languages. He is also accused of other acts that, for many, would reveal a racist mindset. 

However, there are some contradictions too. According to an article by Tristin Hopper published on August 28, 2018, in the National Post, while severe accusations could be made against Macdonald, the author also cites a text in which he acknowledges the aboriginals’ title to this land: “We must remember that they are the original owners of the soil, of which they have been dispossessed by the covetousness or ambition of our ancestors,” he wrote in a letter proposing the creation of the Department of Indian Affairs.

However, the problem now, more than 150 years later is how to balance his action as one of the founders of this nation with the tragic results of one of his most significant policies. Should his statue be subjected to regular attacks? Elsewhere, his statue in Victoria B.C. was simply removed, and teachers in Ontario have demanded that all schools named after him in that province undergo a name change. In the case of Montreal, however, there is an added element: many Quebec separatists may join in attacking the monument not for what Macdonald did to the aboriginals, which they most likely don’t care, but because it allows them to attack Canada too.

And last, but not least, as Montrealers, we shouldn’t forget the aesthetic value of the place: Place du Canada, recently renovated.  The monument was unveiled in 1895, the work of British sculptor George Edward Wade featuring Macdonald under a canopy, which is a beautiful piece of public art.  Do we advance a just political cause by vandalizing the site? Wouldn’t it be better to add on a separate plaque some more balanced historical description? His achievements, including his contribution to the creation of Canada, but also the dreadful policies he implemented regarding the indigenous people, would be described.  Presenting the old historical view that the monument itself represents is fine. That, as long as it goes together with a contemporary, revised assessment of a past with other values, certainly less enlightened. This would undoubtedly help everybody to make up their own minds on the issue. And especially understand that most people, even those immortalized in bronze, have their dark sides as well. Still, I would save the orange paint for other uses.

By: Sergio Martinez – [email protected]

Other articles:

Sir John A. MacDonald Montreal statue not to be removed

Does anyone remember this Montreal hotel?

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Is it possible to get an A for a 5-paragraph essay assignment in 1 hour? We can safely say yes, a student can get an A+ mark if he turns to EduJungles


staycation

The ultimate guide to planning a long family staycation in Canada

To guarantee that everyone has an amazing time, careful planning is necessary when organizing a lengthy staycation. Here’s the ultimate guide to planning your family staycation in Canada. Canada, with its vast landscapes, diverse cities, and rich cultural heritage, offers endless possibilities for a memorable family staycation. Whether you’re exploring the stunning natural beauty of

Meal kits

Cost vs. Convenience: Analyzing meal kits and traditional cooking

In this modern world and modern times, convenience often takes priority over cost, especially when it comes to food. Meal kits and traditional cooking represent two different approaches to home dining, and each of them has advantages and disadvantages. Analyzing these methods through the lens of cost and convenience provides insight into why individuals might

Condo renovations

Condo renovations Dos and Don’ts: Expert Tips for a Successful Project

Embarking on a condo renovations journey can be both exhilarating and daunting. Imagine transforming your living space into a stylish haven that reflects your personality and meets your needs. While exciting, the process can be full of challenges and unforeseen hiccups. That’s why we’ve gathered some condo renovation dos and don’ts from the experts to

Terrific Hair

Terrific Hair Means Tamanu – Earth to Body

Curly, straight, thick, thin, kinky or silky, tamanu loves and makes terrific Hair.  And scalps. Nutritionally dense yet gentle, tamanu is an effective and versatile nut oil. It stimulates, helps promote growth. prevents hair loss, reduces scalp itch and irritations and adds a natural sheen! Make tamanu a part of your hair and scalp care

Understanding the 4 legal process after a DUI Crash

A single mistake can have serious consequences, especially when driving under the influence. The aftermath of a DUI crash extends beyond physical harm and property damage. It involves a complex legal process that may feel overwhelming. As a responsible citizen, it’s vital to grasp the legal system and your rights in such situations. This blog

personal injury lawyer

Pedestrian accident: How a personal injury lawyer can help you

Accidents involving pedestrians can be life-altering. You could be walking down the street or crossing a street. A vehicle’s sudden impact can change everything right away. If you’ve found yourself in such a situation, you might be wondering how to move forward. This is where a personal injury lawyer steps in, offering crucial help and

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox