CAQ Bill 21 creating growing opposition and division


Since the CAQ tabled Bill 21, forbidding public sector employees ‘in position of authority’ from wearing religious symbols at work, opposition against it has been growing, especially in the Montreal area. While Premier Francois Legault appealed for ‘calm and respectful debate’ stating people ‘will come around to accepting and applying the new law in the long run’ and the architect of Bill 21, Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette repeated a robotic-like message as he tried to sell the merits of the legislation wherever he could – voices from human rights organizations and women’s groups to school boards, lawyers as well as borough and suburban mayors have been getting louder.

With a poll showing 74% of Quebecers supporting the legislation (a Leger poll of 1,015 respondents conducted March 22-26 for the CAQ), Premier Legault has repeated he will not hesitate to use the Notwithstanding Clause to stop any legal challenges to Bill 21. With it being criticized as unconstitutional, challenges are expected. Montreal lawyer Catherine McKenzie said they were studying the bill and the possible recourses they could bring against it. She already had success in challenging a part of Bill 62 which was approved in 2017 by the Liberal government (the Act to foster adherence to State religious neutrality).

The Lester B. Pearson School Board (LBPSB) reacted quickly back in February, unanimously passing a resolution against ‘a bill which would infringe on freedom of religious expression’. Last Friday they made their stance clear with the board announcing it ‘would not enforce the CAQ’s Bill 21 as proposed’. Joining in that call was the English Montreal School Board (EMSB) who stated they would also not enforce it and the Quebec English School Boards Association (QESBA) who called Bill 21 ‘divisive’ and ‘an unnecessary piece of legislation that can only lead to societal discrimination… this government is claiming there is a problem that clearly does not exist’ and they will not enforce it.

The borough of CDN/NDG as well as the municipalities of Montreal West and Westmount all stated they will not enforce the bill. In an email exchange with CTV News the Borough mayor of CDN/NDG, Sue Montgomery wrote, ‘We’re not going to tell anyone what to wear.’

In an interview with the Montreal Times newspaper, Mayor Alan DeSousa of Ville Saint-Laurent had his own perspective. When asked where the city stands on the bill he said, “If the bill would be passed today as it is, it would have virtually very little impact on the way we are currently operating and the only thing we would have concern on, is what impact would it have on future hiring’s… for future hiring’s we would do our best efforts to make sure we get the best people, regardless of what they are wearing, but I will have to see what the bill will say in its final form. He then added, “Our wish is to be able to hire the best person who is most qualified… let me be clear there is no way in any shape that I can say I support this bill, but if your question to me is what is the impact of the bill on the community, I can say that at the present time if the bill is implemented as is, there will be very little impact.” When asked where he personally stood on Bill 21 he replied, “Believe me, as far as I’m concerned people should be allowed to wear whatever they wish to wear, as far as part of their religious affiliations, provided it is not detrimental to the quality of their work and their ability to do the job.”

Mayor Valerie Plante, has not yet made clear the city’s stance on the bill except to say they will be taking part in a commission and will be presenting there, bringing forward ‘the realities specific to Montreal’ and they want to defend that. The Quebec Solidaire party, at their national council meeting last weekend, have made it clear they are against Bill 21 after votes were counted. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was concerned it would open the door to discrimination and said that ‘it is unthinkable to me that in a free society, we would legitimize discrimination against citizens based on their religion.’

The controversy even goes beyond Canada’s borders with Amnesty International stating ‘the bill contravenes the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which guarantees freedom of thought, conscience and religion’. What is clear at this point is that Bill 21 is disconcerting to many and hopefully a common and respectful ground will be found.

By: Bonnie Wurst – [email protected]
Is it possible to get an A for a 5-paragraph essay assignment in 1 hour? We can safely say yes, a student can get an A+ mark if he turns to EduJungles

The growing need for international trade lawyers in emerging markets

Emerging markets are becoming key players in the global economy. Countries like China, India, Brazil, and several African nations are growing at a fast pace. But, they face tricky trade rules and regulations that can be hard to navigate. As a result, there is a bigger need for an international trade lawyer to help these

guide to freebies

Claim your free stuff in the mail: Ultimate guide to freebies

Have you ever wondered how some people score all sorts of free stuff in the mail? Imagine opening your mailbox to find beauty samples, snacks, or even tech gadgets waiting for you. This is not just a dream; it can be your reality. In this ultimate guide, learn how to get freebies, where to find


The ultimate guide to planning a long family staycation in Canada

To guarantee that everyone has an amazing time, careful planning is necessary when organizing a lengthy staycation. Here’s the ultimate guide to planning your family staycation in Canada. Canada, with its vast landscapes, diverse cities, and rich cultural heritage, offers endless possibilities for a memorable family staycation. Whether you’re exploring the stunning natural beauty of

Meal kits

Cost vs. Convenience: Analyzing meal kits and traditional cooking

In this modern world and modern times, convenience often takes priority over cost, especially when it comes to food. Meal kits and traditional cooking represent two different approaches to home dining, and each of them has advantages and disadvantages. Analyzing these methods through the lens of cost and convenience provides insight into why individuals might

Condo renovations

Condo renovations Dos and Don’ts: Expert Tips for a Successful Project

Embarking on a condo renovations journey can be both exhilarating and daunting. Imagine transforming your living space into a stylish haven that reflects your personality and meets your needs. While exciting, the process can be full of challenges and unforeseen hiccups. That’s why we’ve gathered some condo renovation dos and don’ts from the experts to

Terrific Hair

Terrific Hair Means Tamanu – Earth to Body

Curly, straight, thick, thin, kinky or silky, tamanu loves and makes terrific Hair.  And scalps. Nutritionally dense yet gentle, tamanu is an effective and versatile nut oil. It stimulates, helps promote growth. prevents hair loss, reduces scalp itch and irritations and adds a natural sheen! Make tamanu a part of your hair and scalp care

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox