Verdict on not holding escalator handrail $320 ticket

STM-Escalators-with-Handrail-Pictograms-copy-min

Over a decade ago, Bela Kosoian was riding an escalator at the STM‘s Montmorency metro station when she was stopped by Laval police for not holding the handrail. The police repeatedly asked her to do so, as they said she was breaking the rules by not respecting a pictogram on the escalator that cautioned ‘Tenir la main courante’ (Hole the handrail). Kosoian refused and was then handcuffed, detained at the station and had her bag searched. After close to 30 minutes she was finally released – with a $100 ticket for ‘failing to hold the rail’ and another a $320 ticket for ‘failing to identify herself’. However, Kosoian was not going to let it end there. This ride was not over as far she was concerned and she went to court to fight the tickets.

Victory for woman who fought not holding escalator handrail $320 ticket

In 2012 she was in Montreal’s municipal court and was acquitted of the two infractions, but then decided to file a $45,000 lawsuit in Quebec Court against the City of Laval, STM and one of the police officers who had detained her, but in 2015 it was rejected. Still determined, she filed another lawsuit in 2017 with the Quebec Court of Appeal, but it was also rejected – with the ruling citing she was the ‘author of her own misfortune’. It would now have to go all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada if she wanted to be vindicated. In November of 2018, the Court agreed to hear her case and on April 16th 2019, Kosoian found herself before the highest court in the country. Lawyers and judges were requested to determine if the pictogram was an order of a STM bylaw, or if it was showing that commuters should hold the handrail as a precautionary measure. After a two hour hearing, the debate became about the responsibility of the Laval police in applying a law that was not clear. Kosoian would now have to wait months for the Court’s decision. Her long ride continued, but this past Friday November 29th, it finally ended, with a ruling that made the long journey worth the trip. The verdict was in and the Supreme Court of Canada had ruled in her favour.

The judgement states in part, ‘A reasonable police officer in the same circumstances would not have considered failure to hold the handrail to be an offence… the STM committed a fault by teaching police officers that the pictogram in question imposed an obligation to hold the handrail, a fault that explains, at least in part, the officer’s conduct.’ The court also ruled that the City of Laval ‘must also be held liable for the officer’s fault’. It goes on to say that ‘she was entitled to refuse to obey an unlawful order, and she, therefore, committed no fault that would justify an apportionment of liability’. The onus has now been put on the STM to properly train their officers in which the judgement declared that police officers cannot simply argue they were carrying out an order they ‘knew or ought to have known’ was unlawful. Bela Kosoian was awarded $20,000 for damages, with the police officer and the STM each liable for half. Although she said to reporters that she was pleased with the judgement and felt it should have never gone all the way to the Supreme Court and taken so long, this decade long ride has pulled into the station.

By: Bonnie Wurst – [email protected]

Other interesting articles:

REM Trudeau Airport station and travel times

Montreal Black Friday Protest

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
safest cities

Why Montreal is one of the safest cities to visit in 2025

If you’re planning a trip to Canada, Montreal has been ranked the sixth safest cities to travel to in 2025, according to a recent report by insurance company Berkshire Hathaway. When you break it down, Montreal’s safety is a combination of aspects that makes this city a favourite destination among safety-conscious travelers. Here’s a look

dermal fillers

The ultimate guide to dermal fillers: Are they worth it?

For decades now, dermal fillers have remained the go-to treatment for fighting the signs of aging, such as lines, wrinkles, and sagging. Apart from these, they are also extensively used to elevate some facial features by adding contour and volume to areas like lips, cheeks, and chin. Although the average cost of a dermal filler

Winnipeg’s Bold Commerce announces new PayPal integrations

Winnipeg’s Bold Commerce announces new PayPal integrations

Bold Commerce has built on its existing long-standing relationship with financial services platform PayPal. The firm has announced that small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Canada currently using its OpenCart and Gravity Forms solutions will benefit from the integration of PayPal’s full payments suite. This includes digital wallets, Venmo, Fastlane, as well as its Buy

Montreal Bungee

Montreal Bungee jumping in the Old Port of Montreal

Get ready, Montreal! The team behind MTL Zipline is taking adrenaline to new heights with Montreal Bungee, a bold new attraction launching in Spring 2025. Set against the stunning backdrop of the Old Port, this is not just another thrill ride—it’s an experience that redefines adventure. Perched at the Convoyeur Tower, the tallest urban jump in Canada

Interpol notices

Understanding Interpol notices and their impact on legal cases

Interpol is the largest international organization facilitating cooperation among law enforcement agencies in over 190 countries. Its notices serve as tools for tracking suspects, locating missing persons, and pursuing international criminals. However, for ordinary citizens, encountering the Interpol system can be challenging and stressful, especially if the notice comes as a surprise. Such situations often

Mtltimes Subscription

The latest on what’s moving Montreal and the world – delivered straight to your inbox